The Novel in Letters

 

      An epistolary novel is written as a series of letters.  It may also contain diary entries, clippings from newspapers or magazines, etc., and more recently, Email. But it is not an epistolary novel unless it is composed primarily of letters.1

     Letters and other primary sources add immediacy and verisimilitude to the novel. They provide variety in the ways a writer can impart information to the reader, break up long passages of narrative summary or dialogue, and allow the writer to express multiple points of view, using numerous characters.

     The first epistolary novel was Aphra Behn’s 1684 three volume Love-Letters Between a Nobleman and His Sister. The novel in letters became popular in

 
 

England in the 18th century, with the 1740 publication of Samuel Richardson’s highly successful Pamela, and in 1748, Clarissa; followed by Tobias Smollett’s 1771 Humphry Clinker, and Fanny Burden’s Evelina of 1778.

     The flood of epistolary novels in England slowed at the end of the 18th century, and the flow sometimes became a trickle, but it never entirely dried up. The best nineteenth century epistolary novel is Jane Austen's 1871 Lady Susan, comprised of letters from the selfish and self-centered title character; the book is a marvelous example of unintentional revelations by and about the woman writing the letters2. See a Jane Austen link, http://www.jasna.org/. But the most famous 19th century epistolary novel is Bram Stoker's 1897 Dracula, composed mostly of letters, but also containing diary entries, a newspaper clipping, and what is listed in the table of contents as a "phonograph diary."

     The first U.S. novel, The Power of Sympathy, published in 1789, was in epistolary form, and was once thought to have been written by Sarah Wentworth Morton. That attribution is now uncertain, and the book is rarely read. A number of forgotten books in letters were published in the U.S.A. in the late eighteenth and nineteenth centuries3, but it was not until the twentieth century that U.S. writers produced epistolary novels that were both popular and memorable.

     The popularity of epistolary novels in the U.S. grew in the twentieth century just as interest in the genre was fading in Europe4. Jean Webster's charming 1912 Daddy-Long-Legs was a best-seller, a successful play, and inspired two films, including one starring Fred Astaire in the 1950s. Daddy-Long-Legs's sequel, Dear Enemy, published in 1915, also became a best-seller. Both are still fun to read.

     John O'Hara's 64-page paperback (it sold for ten cents), Pal Joey of 1939,5 began its life in 1938 as fictional letters from Pal Joey to Pal Ted in The New Yorker. The collected letters formed a popular novel, and in 1941 became a hit musical, with music by Rodgers and Hammerstein.

     The letters in Helene Hanff's 1970 novel, 84, Charing Cross Road, later a successful play, are by an American author writing to a London book dealer over a twenty year period beginning in 1946.

     John Barth's 769 page Letters of 1979 is definitely an epistolary novel; he even uses "An Old Time Epistolary Novel" as a subtitle. In the foreword, he describes the book as "eighty-eight epistles from seven correspondents" (XIX), and characterizes it as "complicated," while quoting others who have used the words "interminable," and "unreadable" (xvii) to describe the book.

     The best known twentieth century epistolary novel is Alice Walker's The Color Purple of 1982, which won both the Pulitzer Prize and the American Book Award for Fiction. Walker's protagonist, Celie, writes her sad letters to God, and to her sister.

     The ways in which writers have used the epistolary form seem almost limitless. George Plimpton, best known for his elegant prose and a founder of The Paris Review, wrote the hilarious Pet Peeves or Whatever Happened to Doctor Rawff, published in 2000, which consists of letters to a pet problem advice columnist and veterinarian.

     Mary Ann Shaffer's delightful and extraordinarily popular 2008 The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society has been published in thirteen countries, and occupies numerous "Best-seller" lists. Set in 1946 in Guernsey, the writer used letters, hand-delivered notes, cables, telegrams, night letters, and "detection notes" to tell her story. Part of its convincing tone comes from some of the obsolete types of epistles employed.

     With the advent of Email, writers began to utilize it in novels. Many early Email books are available only online, or are no longer unavailable, but a growing number can be bought in bookstores, or borrowed from libraries. Among them are:

     Avodah Offit's Virtual Love of 1994 composed of Emails between two therapists about sexual dysfunction; Stephanie Fletcher's 1996 Email, A Love Story, made up of Email and electronic bulletin-board posts; the 2002 ChaseR: A Novel in Emails by Michael Rosen told from the point of view of a fourteen year old boy; Cecelia Ahern's 453 page Where Rainbows End of 2004 composed of notes written in class by children, Valentine cards, instant messages, notes from teachers to parents, bills, text messages, Email, Christmas cards, newspaper clippings, faxes, post cards, birthday cards, etc.; and Lucy Kellaway's Who Moved My Blackberry? of 2006, an amusing business satire set in England, composed of Email, interoffice memos, and text messages mostly from Martin Lukes, an obnoxious executive on his way down. It resembles Lady Susan in that Lukes unintentionally reveals just how awful he is through his correspondence.

     As to the future of the epistolary novel, the growing number of Email novels suggest that the future is now. The U.S. Postal Service was described on August 8, 2009 in The New York Times as "today's Pony Express," and snail mail may, like telegrams, become obsolete. Where the electronic world takes us, for better or worse, writers will surely follow.

     I find two types of epistolary novel especially interesting, regardless of the form of the epistles. The first is the novel (like Lady Susan and Who Moved my Blackberry?), which the letter writer unintentionally reveals his or her true character.

     The second type is Shaffer's The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society, in which the type of epistles authenticates the novel's time frame. But when establishing that the book takes place in the twenty-first century, the writer should take care not to overdo it. Ahern's Where Rainbows End is overwhelming in length and in the number of types of epistles used.

     Finally, those interested in epistolary novels might like the "letter story." Other People's Mail, 2000, an anthology of letter (or epistolary) stories edited and introduced by Gail Pool, was a revelation, and includes interesting works by many well-known authors.
_______________________________________________  

 1 "Epistolary" is an adjective, meaning related to the writing of letters or literary works in the form of letters (New Oxford Dictionary.) In my search for epistolary novels, I encountered many imposters. The culprits who spread the bad information seem to be those who make lists for the Internet. They copy each other's lists, thus perpetuating errors.

2 Some Janeites have used the epistolary form for writing "After Janes." See Paula Atchia's Mansfield Letters, a sequel to Mansfield Park, 1996; Jane Dawkin's Letters from Pemberley, the First Year: a continuation of Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice, 1999, and More Letters from Pemberley, 2003.

3 For a long list of pre-twentieth century epistolary novels published in the U.S., see Godfrey Frank Singer, The Epistolary Novel, 1933, Chapter IX, "Epistolary Fiction in America."

4 Among the epistolary novels published in England in the early twentieth century was Dorothy L. Sayer's The Documents in the Case, 1930, which uses the form to present an absorbing murder mystery.

5 The caption on the book jacket is "a crooner not above borrowing for keeps from any reasonably attractive mouse," and is described on the title page as "About a Hard-Luck Guy and His Babes."